On CC licenses stickiness

If you rushed on CC licenses because they're cool, did you take the time to read them before choosing one?

Dave Shea, who launched the CSS Zen Garden, released the CSS files under an Attribution-ShareAlike license from Creative Commons. But now Dave complains that someone wants to use them as is in an open source CMS.

The comments attached to Dave's post are enlightening of the misconceptions regarding CC licenses. It's only at #7 that someone hints that picking the by-sa license may not have been a good idea, at #8 that nothing illegal was done, #8 and #12 that you cannot override CC licenses with your own terms, and only at #17 that the CC licenses are irrevocable!

I think many people have overlooked the fact that there is no legal way to revoke a CC license. Apply one to something once, it will stick forever. This is actually a good protection, for those licenses are to foster creative reuse and nobody wants to receive a cease and desist letter for something that was once published in this spirit.

CC licenses are legal contracts, you should read the fine-prints carefully.

1 Comment

CC licenses are legal contracts, you should read the fine-prints carefully

But that's not the way of the world. It's use it today because it's cool and then complain tomorrow it was too complicated.

Leave a comment

mensuelles Archives

Recent Entries

  • On Apple Safari's use of justified text in Reader

    On my professional blog, a take on Apple Safari's use of justified text in Reader....

  • Curated computing

    Perhaps the most pernicious proposition of the “everything must be open” crusade is the notion that curation is bad and anti-freedom. Soldiers of this crusade...

  • Death by Apple, the obsolescence of Flash

    Flash was created during the PC era – for PCs and mice. Flash is a successful business for Adobe, and we can understand why they...

  • Ogg (and Mozilla) objections

    Ogg objections by Måns: When challenged, three types of reaction are characteristic of the Ogg campaigners. On occasion, these people will assume an apologetic tone,...

  • Paris Web 2010 — Call for speakers

    (Disclaimer: I manage the communication for Paris Web, this is a copy of the official call for speakers.) Hello all, Paris Web is a French...